A Book Ban, For Real

June 23, 2023

Community attendance at Board of Education meetings remains critical. It’s essential for parents and residents to monitor key decisions poised to affect the coming school year in many different respects. At the June 12th meeting, the district approved the hiring of two Assistant Principals, bringing the total number of APs to 11 for the first time since November 2022. Feedback from PTO presidents and parents was instrumental in keeping AP and teaching positions for the 2023-24 school year, despite a push by some Board members to reduce staffing. 

It was announced at this meeting, that the Board is in the process of reexamining its decision to not approve two textbooks recommended by history teachers and their supervisor. A second vote was expected at an added June 22nd BOE meeting. The textbooks, including “Sociology: A Brief Introduction” by Richard T. Schaefer, would replace an outdated and inaccessible 2014 textbook currently in use for an elective course at Ridge High. 

As a reminder, nearly 100 area residents attended the May 8th BOE meeting to object to Board members’ votes against the textbooks as bordering on book banning. This vote came after nearly five months of debate and controversy, which garnered the attention of state and national press. 

Also scheduled to be voted on at the June 22nd meeting were revisions to the district’s 2020 Health and Physical Education Curriculum. Online surveys have been posted on the district website inviting feedback from families with students in the schools as well as community members; to date, 384 families and 271 community members have responded. Their responses will help to consolidate standards that many find objectionable and will provide curriculum writers ways to adapt lesson plans to better satisfy those who have concerns about content.

When the June 22nd meeting was held, the Board did in fact reject the Schaefer sociology textbook, with members Csipak, Light, Molinari, and Rascio objecting to its content. One objection concerns the book’s statement that increasing costs are causing some to question starting families. Other topics, related to various family and gender issues, were deemed inappropriate for the classroom as well. The Health and Phys Ed topics were not re-addressed at this meeting. 

The banning of textbooks recommended by district teachers and supervisors serves as a stark reminder – the upcoming Board of Education elections in November are very consequential. To date, six applicants have filed as candidates for the November 7th school board election. They include incumbent Board member Jennifer White, in addition to Janice Corrado and David Shaw. Running on a Securing Kids’ Education ticket are incumbent Larry Rascio, as well as Deborah Marcus and Erin Weber.  

leave a comment+

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. David J. Shuffler says:

    Good newsletter.

    Please post the pro and con votes on the books which were banned. It’ll be helpful in deciding who to vote for in the November 7th election.

    Thank you.

    • Bernards Township Democratic Committee says:

      Thank you David. There are two incumbents running this term: They are Larry Rascio and Jennifer White. Mr. Rascio voted against the textbook and Ms. White voted for it.


True Blue

Civic Scholarship Winner Lucy Brodkin

If young people are the future of the Democratic party, Ridge High School junior Lucy Brodkin gives us much cause for optimism. Brodkin, this year’s winner of the BTDC Civic Scholarship, given to a Ridge student entering their senior year or first year of college who is an enthusiastic proponent of civic engagement and democratic […]

The BTDC is proud to introduce candidates Liz Graner and Adam Subervi

True Blue

True Blue 2024: Meet Our Candidates

True Blue

True Blue: Joan Bannan

Few people embody the true spirit of public service like Joan Bannan. A trailblazer who became the first Democrat to serve on the Bernards Township Committee in decades, as well as the first female Democrat ever elected to the governing body, Bannan’s resume reflects a tireless commitment to community and to breaking down partisan walls. […]

How Culture Wars Lead to Book Bans


Professor Mary Nolan, a scholar, historian, and professor emeritus at New York University, spoke about book bans, educational gag orders, and censorship to a packed house at the Bernards Township Library on March 28th. The rapt audience, comprised of community members from across the political spectrum, learned volumes about the current culture wars being fought […]

read latest issue

The BTDC Beat

our monthly newsletter

Get the beat

Subscribe to The BTDC Beat and get the latest on events around town, newsworthy topics and great information!
No spam, only good info.